Welcome to Penn Street Pizza
Penn Street Pizza, located at 500 W Penn St in Butler, PA, is a beloved local gem known for its delicious hand-tossed pizzas and inviting atmosphere. What sets this family-owned establishment apart is its commitment to quality; customers rave about the generous portions and fresh ingredients. Highlights include the classic pepperoni and onion pizza, renowned for its bold flavors, and the well-crafted hoagies that offer a delightful twist on traditional fare. With friendly service and competitive prices, Penn Street Pizza has quickly become a favorite for takeout and delivery, making it the go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts in the community.
Penn Street Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
My new favorite local pizza shop! I get the hand tossed pepperoni and onion pizza. Generous portions on toppings. Always fresh and awesome price!
* UPDATE* Tonight was my 2nd time ordering for delivery. This time I ordered the steak and cheese hoagie (hold the tomato and Italian dressing) and AGAIN, the food was out of this world for a pizza place! I loved how they cut my sub in half and wrapped each half individually in foil -- perfect, because I'm saving the other half for lunch tomorrow. Added, the delivery guy (M) is a really good kid. Penn Street Pizza is definitely my new go-to for ordering out. First time review: First time ordering and everything about it was superb, from taking my phone order, the price for an excellent (!) pizza (LG w/ sausage/black olives/onions), and the free, fast, and friendly delivery. I'm so glad that a friend turned me on to this place today. Only wish I knew about it sooner!
Great pizza, the Buffalo wings were lacking though, a bit dried out. Pizza was delicious!
This has been one of our favorites for yrs. Talking about taking care of a family owned business this is truly one that will not and has not ever been a disappointment. Our go to is the toco pizza but have tried other items and still just as good.
We ordered for the first time, hoping this would be our new favorite pizza spot since; they had great reviews online and offered free delivery, plus, 19.99 for a large pizza, plus garlic sticks, and a soda! That’s a STEAL compared to most chain or overhyped pizza places Customer service over the phone was a 10/10. They delivered when stated and when I tell you the pizza was PIPING HOT when it arrived! It was PIPING HOT! The delivery guy was very nice and of course, we tipped well because we plan on ordering on a regular basis! Would have taken a picture of the pizza but we dug right on and couldn’t wait!!
Local family owned and operated business. Great low cost pizza. When you’re hungry, in a hurry, and eating out on a budget Penn Street Pizza is a fantastic option. Specials every Monday. S, M, L, XL (16 cut), and 24 cut options. S - XL pizza use a premade shell. The 24 cut pizza uses fresh hand tossed dough. A 24 cut hand tossed fresh dough pizza here costs less than a 12 cut pizza does elsewhere.
I ordered the taco pizza last night .....it was delicious!! I've heard good things about penn st pizza and this was my first time ordering! I'll definitely be back to try other things!!
I got a small cheese pizza a turkey bacon and cheddar hoagie and a sirloin bacon and cheddar hoagie and it was all really good. For the price the quality was beyond what I paid. They told me an hour to an hour and 15 minutes and the delivery driver got here in 45. He was super nice and told me the food would be good. The cheese pizza was great the bottom crust was crispy and the pizza for 5 bucks for a 4 cut was really good. I’ll be eating here again for sure.
Location
-
500 W Penn St, Butler, PA 16001, United States Hotline: +1 724-285-7200
Welcome to Penn Street Pizza, a gem nestled in the heart of Butler, PA! Located at 500 W Penn St, this family-owned pizzeria has quickly become a local favorite, and for good reason. Known for its hand-tossed pizzas, generous toppings, and great prices, Penn Street Pizza is not just a place to grab a slice; it's a community staple.
From the moment you place your order at +1 724-285-7200, you can feel the warmth of genuine service. Customers rave about the superb customer experience, whether it's through friendly interactions over the phone or the punctual delivery service. One satisfied diner, Jennifer Bole, shares her passion for their hand-tossed pepperoni and onion pizza, highlighting the freshness of the ingredients and the generous portions that keep her coming back for more.
The menu at Penn Street Pizza goes beyond just pizza. The reviews suggest that their steak and cheese hoagie is a delightful surprise, offering flavors that soar above the typical expectations for a pizza joint. DianeM's experience speaks volumes, noting the meticulous care in preparation and the thoughtful packaging for takeout — perfect for those who love to save some for later.
Of course, no pizzeria is complete without some wings, and while a few diners noted room for improvement in that area, the overall consensus is that pizza reigns supreme here. The standout dish for many is the unique and lively taco pizza, which has been a long-time favorite for regulars like Jolyn Burns. It's this dedication to quality and consistency that has made Penn Street Pizza a beloved establishment for years.
What truly sets Penn Street Pizza apart is its value. Promotions that include large pizzas, garlic sticks, and drinks for under $20 make it an easy choice for families or those looking to satisfy a pizza craving without breaking the bank. Carlie Soto's first experience highlights just how fresh and hot the food arrives, making it an irresistible temptation for anyone who orders.
In essence, Penn Street Pizza is more than just a meal; it’s a delightful experience that combines quality ingredients, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re picking up dinner for the family or stopping by for a quick slice, this pizzeria embodies the heart of local dining. Indulge in the flavors, enjoy the service, and discover why Penn Street Pizza has earned its reputation as the go-to spot for delicious, comforting pizzas in Butler.